
By Ahan S. Prakash
A constitutional republic does not usually collapse in some spectacular, cinematic way. There is rarely a dramatic coup at midnight or a sudden tearing up of the constitution. Instead, it is a process, a slow, grinding campaign of administrative takeover, covert subversions, and the quiet rewiring of institutions. Take India as a case in point. People used to hold up its post colonial democracy as a sturdy bulwark against the rising tide of regional authoritarianism. On paper, the major institutions are still there. The structure is unchanged, the language of the constitution untouched. But underneath that surface, over the past twelve years, Prime Minister Narendra Modi, Home Minister Amit Shah, and National Security Advisor Ajit Doval have remade the republic. They have drained autonomy from its core and, piece by piece, replaced neutral institutions with an ideological machine.
This transformation is not just something cooked up by critics. It is spilling out, undeniable, from the highest reaches of the state now. Let us look at what has come out recently. Former Supreme Court Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul’s memoir pulled back the curtain, revealing that Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud caved to executive pressure on crucial occasions, even withdrawing challenges to the government’s interference in judicial appointments. And The Indian Express, through old school investigative digging, showed how two Election Commissioners ignored established legal process while revising the country’s electoral rolls, a blow to the credibility of free and fair elections. If the judiciary and the Election Commission, supposed to be backbone institutions holding the executive in check, collapse into submission, the idea of a democratic republic becomes a fiction.
If backbone institutions like the judiciary and the Election Commission collapse into submission, the idea of a democratic republic becomes a fiction.
This did not happen by accident. It was executed step by step, starting with neutralizing the judiciary. The tone was set tragically. Judge B.H. Loya, presiding over a case loaded with political consequences, died under bewildering, suspicious circumstances. Then the legal system just shrugged it off, burying the investigation. A chilling message went out: push back and you are on your own. Play along, and you might get a plum appointment after retirement, just like former Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi, who zipped straight into the Rajya Sabha. Judges who resisted were demoted, sidelined, erased from relevance.
With the judiciary brought to heel, the sweep continued into the raw power centers: security agencies and armed forces. Agencies once protected by law from political meddling suddenly became tools of enforcement and propaganda. Back in 2015, public prosecutor Rohini Salian came forward. She had been told by the National Investigation Agency to go soft on right wing terror cases. The next year, the government broke decades old military traditions, promoting General Bipin Rawat over better qualified candidates, showing that loyalty, not merit, was the new rule.
And that is not all. The military itself started absorbing political and ideological messaging. Military doctrine and planning now come bundled with initiatives like Project Udbhav, which pulls strategic inspiration from ancient texts. The defence staff find themselves attending lectures on religious scripture. Meanwhile, investigative agencies were reshaped to fit the executive’s narrative, and even shield sensitive defense acquisitions from scrutiny. It came to a head when CBI Director Alok Verma was summarily ousted in the middle of investigating defense deals. Accountability died that night. When four senior Supreme Court justices tried to sound the alarm at a press conference in 2018, saying, on record, that democracy was at risk, much of the world looked away, dazzled by India’s economic lure.
To really control a nation, you do not just grab the levers of power; you control the numbers, the narrative, and the administrative machinery.
But to really control a nation, you do not just grab the levers of power. You control the numbers and the narrative. In 2019, when the government suppressed a startling unemployment report, senior members of the National Statistical Commission resigned. They had had enough. On the security front, official secrecy became obsession. Years passed with government spokespeople insisting India’s borders were secure, even as frontline troops grappled with the messy, dangerous reality. Only recently did the Indo Tibetan Border Police chief admit that tense standoffs were ongoing with Chinese forces in Arunachal Pradesh, exposing years of official denial.
The story repeated itself in the softer organs of democracy. Universities and research bodies got a very deliberate makeover: packed with ideological loyalists, led by vice chancellors handpicked to squash protest. Vague anti terror laws gave the state new power to label critics, from activists to professors, as urban Naxals, making dissent itself a punishable offense. Well respected scholars were ridiculed, fired, or forced out, while private institutions, feeling government or corporate heat, chose silence over confrontation. A generation is growing up without the intellectual tools to push back on manufactured narratives.
And it is not just about holding power now. The changes are built to last, designed to outlive any change in government. Through lateral entry, ideologues with no competitive exam record were slotted into senior civil service posts, bypassing the old, independent UPSC process. Loyalists were seeded throughout the bureaucracy, and the National Security Council Secretariat became a parallel power center. It is a machine set to keep running in the same direction no matter who claims the chair of the prime minister.
So what is an opposition to do at this point? This is not a job you can finish in a single term, or by playing by the old rulebook. Real repair requires more than polite procedures; it needs a full, fearless audit of how government actually works now. New leaders cannot just install diplomats and expect the rot to reverse; they need skilled operators who understand both the inner workings and the defense mechanisms of this new state.
But the deepest tragedy is not just the corruption at the top. It is the toll on public faith, on ordinary people’s trust that democracy can work for them. Winning that back is not easy. It demands a hard, honest commitment to the rule of law, and the courage to stand up against the suffocating machinery of state capture. That is the only way to start rebuilding belief in the promise of self government.
About the Author
Ahan S. Prakash is a Geopolitical analyst and columnist covering South Asian affairs, strategic security, and international relations.