
By Daniel Frost
There has been a whirlwind of diplomatic activity lately, with envoys jetting between Abu Dhabi, Moscow, and Dublin, creating the sudden illusion that big progress is brewing in the Ukraine war. Every time high profile diplomats cross continents in a hurry, you get headline after headline. But beneath all those press briefings and private meetings, there is a much harsher truth. Almost five years since Russian tanks rolled across the border in February 2022, outlasting even World War I, the two sides are still worlds apart in what they mean by peace. The latest talks in the UAE led to an agreement to swap over a thousand prisoners from each side. That is honestly great news for the families involved, but let us not kid ourselves: a prisoner exchange does not end a war. The real issues, territory and the architecture of security in Europe, are not resolved, so any talk of a breakthrough is pretty much just for show.
There is another layer to all this, though. American mediation picked up pace not because the battlefield changed, but because Washington has its own political clock ticking. After the November 3 midterms, Republicans lost both the House and Senate. With a Democratic Congress taking over on January 3, President Donald Trump suddenly faced tough limits on foreign aid, sanctions, and just about any executive action he wanted to take. Pile on top of that the administration’s failure to escape the mess with Iran, and it is clear the White House is scrambling to claim some kind of foreign policy win before the year ends. The pressure to deliver something, anything, has sent special envoys Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff racing to pull together a peace framework. But history shows that when you rush a complicated peace process just to meet election deadlines, the weaker side often bears the brunt.
That pressure was all over Kyiv this week. On November 14, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy told reporters that American negotiators asked something pretty shocking: would Ukraine pull out of the last bits of eastern Donbas if it meant joining NATO? Zelenskyy explained he does not have the power to surrender territory on his own, but he would let the people decide with a referendum, if there were real reconstruction and security guarantees. Yet what the Americans proposed highlights a huge contradiction. Moscow’s main reason for invading has always been to keep Ukraine out of the Western military alliance. Asking Kyiv to give up fortified, industrial areas in exchange for a NATO spot, something Putin has vowed to block by force, makes no sense for either side. It satisfies none of their non negotiable demands.
When you rush a complicated peace process just to meet election deadlines, the weaker side often bears the brunt while core security issues remain unresolved.
Looking at Moscow’s stance, you see the Kremlin is not just arguing over which trenches belong to whom. Back in autumn 2022, Russia actually wrote four Ukrainian regions, Donetsk, Luhansk, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson, into its domestic constitution. Russian troops hold nearly all of Luhansk, about eighty percent of Donetsk, but they do not control all of Zaporizhzhia or Kherson. Despite that, Moscow keeps insisting on total Ukrainian withdrawal from all four as a starting point for peace. Putin’s ambitions go even further. He is using the Ukraine conflict to try and break down the whole post Cold War security system in Europe. Russian negotiators want NATO pushed back to where it was in May 1997, meaning Washington and Brussels would give up their grip on Eastern Europe. Leaked military records show Russia has suffered about 450,000 casualties, but with steady territorial gains, the Kremlin sees no reason to give up its bigger goals while the West looks divided and shaky.
On the other side, European capitals are pretty nervous about Washington and Moscow hashing out continental security arrangements without them. At the Dublin meeting on November 12, European leaders made it clear: Ukraine’s fate cannot be decided without Kyiv, and European security cannot move forward without Europe in the room. That is part of a bigger awakening happening across Europe. According to the 2026 GLOBSEC Trends survey, covering eleven EU member states, support for a common European army has jumped to seventy one percent. Years of Russian aggression, plus the nagging doubt about America’s reliability, have convinced European voters and policymakers that relying on Washington is not enough. They want their continent to stand on its own feet militarily.
All these clashing priorities are exactly why real peace remains out of reach. Washington wants a fast diplomatic fix before January. Moscow wants recognition of its territorial gains and a weaker West. Brussels wants control over its own security future. Kyiv wants guarantees that a ceasefire will not just give Russia time to regroup and invade again down the road.
You cannot build lasting peace on vague promises or forced handovers of territory; genuine diplomacy requires patience and concrete security guarantees.
You cannot build lasting peace on vague promises or forced handovers of territory. History is full of deals made under pressure that only pause fighting, not stop it. As millions of Ukrainians endure another brutal winter, facing destroyed power grids and relentless attacks, genuine diplomacy calls for patience, not political deadlines. Unless Moscow is convinced that military force cannot redraw borders, and unless Ukraine gets concrete security guarantees backed by real power, all this diplomatic buzz is just the opening act. The real story is still ahead in what has become Europe’s deadliest war in eighty years.
About the Author
Daniel Frost is a Foreign affairs columnist specializing in global geopolitics, European security, and strategic policy.