Okay, let’s get this out of the way right now: The Real World didn’t kill MTV. I mean, it’s not completely innocent. But the death of music television is not solely the fault of what many consider to be the first modern reality TV show.
The first season of The Real World graced our television screens in May of 1992. And while we were collectively fascinated by the people showcased in the first few seasons, especially Pedro Zamora and Puck, it wasn’t the death blow that brought the network down.
The truth is, MTV was already hurt and limping before Real World hit the small screen. And, sadly, the numbers back this claim up. So, like any business, MTV started pivoting to attract more eyeballs.
And it worked… for a while, at least.
MTV’s Shift to Reality TV: A Breakdown
MTV didn’t replace music videos with trash TV just because some executive wanted to see it on the network. The number of people watching music videos was already on the decline, so MTV decided to change things up to keep making as much money as possible.
Is that the wrong move? Not really. Does it still suck that it happened? Absolutely.
Back in 1992, when season 1 of The Real World debuted, 60 percent of American households had cable television. And at the time, MTV was the pop culture center of the world—especially for young people.
While the network made its name with music videos, people were already beginning to switch from MTV to one of the many other channels popping up at the time. Channels like Cartoon Network, Comedy Central, FX, and Court TV all began in the early to mid-1990s.
Fast forward to 2015, and now 76 percent of Americans had cable or satellite TV. But that number dropped back down to 56 percent in 2021 and is currently hovering around 36 percent in 2025. Simply put, people aren’t watching MTV anymore because they don’t have cable. It’s a dead medium.
Now, 91 percent of Americans own a smartphone. YouTube (and in some ways, TikTok) has replaced Carson Daly as our source for all things music and music videos. And we can’t blame MTV for that, because that change is all on us.
What Happened to MTV: A breakdown
Let’s be real here, MTV was always chasing the money. Its biggest hits in the late 90s and early 2000s weren’t music shows; they were trashy reality TV.
As much as we all love and miss TRL, the show only drew around 800,000 viewers at its peak in the early 2000s. At that same time, The Real World was gaining 3.5 million viewers per episode.
The numbers don’t lie; people wanted what they wanted. And MTV gave it to them in spades.
Jersey Shore premiered a few years later, drawing 8.8 million viewers in 2011. Teen Mom 2 didn’t have the same success, but it still scored 3–4 million viewers, which was massive when compared to TRL. Even The Hills, which I had forgotten about until researching for this article, hit 4.8 million viewers back in 2008.
The people had spoken. They’d much rather watch someone stalk Pauly D’s life on the boardwalk than an hour of grunge music videos.
The Death of the VMAs
Even the MTV VMAs, which were one of the biggest pop culture events of the year in their prime, eventually fell off.
Eight million people tuned in to watch the 1999 VMAs—my personal favorite edition of the award show. Surprisingly, that number was around 12 million in 2012.
Last month, only 5.5 million people watched the VMAs—and that was up from 2024, thanks to Paramount airing the show on CBS instead of MTV for the first time. They also went with a very nostalgia-heavy show, featuring live performances from both Mariah Carey and Busta Rhymes. That strategy most likely helped with the number.
It sounds obvious at this point, but the music era of MTV is officially dead. Paramount is shutting down 5 of the network’s remaining music channels at the end of the year. We’ll still have the flagship network, which at this point is just Rob Dyrdek’s personal YouTube channel on cable TV.
So, if you’re looking for someone to blame for the rise and fall of MTV, it can be easy to point your finger at The Real World. It was obviously cheap to produce, and thus, allowed MTV to make as much money as possible.
But the money was there to be made because of the viewer—and, more specifically, their viewing habits. Once advertisers saw how many people were watching Laguna Beach and Jersey Shore, the idea of music television was quickly put to bed.
Sadly, for music fans, the majority of MTV viewers wanted chaos, drama, and those backroom confessionals more than they wanted Headbanger’s Ball. It wasn’t MTV or reality TV that killed the video star; it was the people.
MTV gave us what we wanted—or at least what the numbers said we wanted—and that’s how we got here.
The post Did ‘The Real World’ Kill MTV? appeared first on VICE.